Your cart is currently empty.
Items remain in your shopping cart for 30 days.

Subtotal $0.00
110% Lowest Price Guarantee

Valentine Exchange Cards

(54 total)

Find Valentine's Day exchange cards and Valentine Card boxes, plus Valentine Candy and supplies for your sweethearts!

Sort Results By:
 
Show:
Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

IN-/K9

$15.99

36 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Valentine Cards with Cars

Valentine Cards with Cars

IN-13629091

$7.20 $4.88

Per Dozen


3.8 out of 5

Truck Valentine Cards

Truck Valentine Cards

IN-13674511

$3.10 $2.18

24 Piece(s)

Disney® Planes Valentine Candy Card Kit

Disney® Planes Valentine Candy Card Kit

IN-13694760

$4.99 $2.48

28 Piece(s)


1.0 out of 5

Robot Mini Sticker Scene Valentine Cards

Robot Mini Sticker Scene Valentine Cards

IN-13627758

$4.40 $2.98

24 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Valentine Mustache Favor Boxes

Valentine Mustache Favor Boxes

IN-13631678

$4.00 $1.98

Per Dozen


5.0 out of 5

Laffy Taffy® Valentine Exchange Cards

Laffy Taffy® Valentine Exchange Cards

IN-13674586

$9.99

24 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Buggy Valentine Candy Fun Packs

Buggy Valentine Candy Fun Packs

IN-13674598

$6.99 $2.48

18 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Tart Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

Tart Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

IN-/K300

$15.99

36 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

You Rule Valentines with Ruler

You Rule Valentines with Ruler

IN-13674471

$12.50

Per Dozen

Mini Valentine Card Games

Mini Valentine Card Games

IN-32/1547

$7.99

24 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Valentine Sticker Sheet Cards

Valentine Sticker Sheet Cards

IN-13627732

$4.25 $2.08

24 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Stretch Bead Rings with Heart Cards

Stretch Bead Rings with Heart Cards

IN-24/2695

$6.00 $4.18

24 Piece(s)


3.5 out of 5

Scripture Valentine Cards & Pops

Scripture Valentine Cards & Pops

IN-/K886

$7.25

32 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Joke Spiders in Valentine Candy Boxes

Joke Spiders in Valentine Candy Boxes

IN-13675135

$5.50

Per Dozen


4.3 out of 5

Sizzlin’ Valentine Suckers with Cards

Sizzlin’ Valentine Suckers with Cards

IN-13674604

$5.50

Per Dozen


4.5 out of 5

Valentine Filled Sticker Boxes

Valentine Filled Sticker Boxes

IN-13631681

$5.25

24 Piece(s)


4.2 out of 5

Plush Valentine Owls

Plush Valentine Owls

IN-32/1549

$17.99

Per Dozen


4.5 out of 5

Mustache Valentine Cards with Pencils

Mustache Valentine Cards with Pencils

IN-13627736

$16.99

24 Piece(s)


3.0 out of 5

Shark Valentine Cards

Shark Valentine Cards

IN-13674514

$3.10 $2.68

24 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Sweet on Jesus Valentine Cards

Sweet on Jesus Valentine Cards

IN-13674671

$3.10

24 Piece(s)

Ladybug Valentine Mailbox Craft Kit

Ladybug Valentine Mailbox Craft Kit

IN-48/6430

$15.99

Makes 12


4.1 out of 5

Jesus Loves You Candy Sticks with Card

Jesus Loves You Candy Sticks with Card

IN-13625877

$10.00 $6.58

24 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Valentine Mailbox Craft Kit

Valentine Mailbox Craft Kit

IN-48/6410

$15.99

Makes 12


3.7 out of 5

Valentine Boxes

Valentine Boxes

IN-32/408

$7.99

Per Dozen


5.0 out of 5

Piece of God’s Love Eraser Valentine Cards

Piece of God’s Love Eraser Valentine Cards

IN-13674648

$5.70

24 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Valentine Mini Treat Bags with Tape

Valentine Mini Treat Bags with Tape

IN-32/1307

$2.99

Per Dozen


4.4 out of 5

Mustache Valentine

Mustache Valentine "To/From" Exchange Suckers on Card

IN-32/1508

$9.99

24 Piece(s)


3.9 out of 5

Valentine Coloring Sheets with Crayons

Valentine Coloring Sheets with Crayons

IN-13627755

$16.00 $6.38

24 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Heart Valentine Cards with Bendable Pencil

Heart Valentine Cards with Bendable Pencil

IN-13627738

$16.99 $13.98

24 Piece(s)


2.8 out of 5

Dino-Mite Eraser Valentine Cards

Dino-Mite Eraser Valentine Cards

IN-13674524

$9.99

24 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Happy Valentine’s Day From Your Teacher Pencils

Happy Valentine’s Day From Your Teacher Pencils

IN-13674533

$16.99

24 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Winner Medal Valentines

Winner Medal Valentines

IN-13674487

$16.99

24 Piece(s)

Heart Erasers with Arrow Pencils & Topper Cards

Heart Erasers with Arrow Pencils & Topper Cards

IN-13674452

$16.99

24 Piece(s)

I Dig You! Valentine Candy Fun Packs

I Dig You! Valentine Candy Fun Packs

IN-13625880

$7.25 $2.88

20 Piece(s)


3.4 out of 5

Butterfly Valentines with Pencils

Butterfly Valentines with Pencils

IN-13674465

$16.99

24 Piece(s)

Superhero Valentines

Superhero Valentines

IN-13674508

$4.15

24 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Inch Worm Valentine To/From Cards with Pencils

Inch Worm Valentine To/From Cards with Pencils

IN-13627765

$16.99

24 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Mini Valentine Exchange Playing Cards

Mini Valentine Exchange Playing Cards

IN-32/1334

$7.99

24 Piece(s)


4.7 out of 5

Valentine’s Day Spiral Notepad Mini Sticker Scenes

Valentine’s Day Spiral Notepad Mini Sticker Scenes

IN-13674645

$12.50

24 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Valentine Message in A Bottle with Candy Powder

Valentine Message in A Bottle with Candy Powder

IN-32/862

$8.50

Per Dozen


4.3 out of 5

Valentine Cards with Fortune Cookie Erasers

Valentine Cards with Fortune Cookie Erasers

IN-13674373

$10.00 $6.58

Per Dozen


3.0 out of 5

Small Valentine Gift Boxes

Small Valentine Gift Boxes

IN-26/1720

$4.25 $3.38

Per Dozen


3.0 out of 5

Mustache Lip Whistle Valentine Card

Mustache Lip Whistle Valentine Card

IN-13629098

$6.99

24 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Tic-Tac-Toe Valentine Sticker Cards

Tic-Tac-Toe Valentine Sticker Cards

IN-13627752

$4.40

24 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Dr. Seuss™ Valentine Cards

Dr. Seuss™ Valentine Cards

IN-13683079

$2.05

32 Piece(s)

I Think You Are Just Write Valentine Pencils

I Think You Are Just Write Valentine Pencils

IN-13674482

$16.99 $13.98

24 Piece(s)

Army Guy Valentine Cards with Erasers

Army Guy Valentine Cards with Erasers

IN-13628024

$5.70

24 Piece(s)


4.7 out of 5

Plush Valentine Sharks

Plush Valentine Sharks

IN-13627187

$15.99

Per Dozen


3.3 out of 5

We Go Together Valentine Cards

We Go Together Valentine Cards

IN-13627744

$3.10

24 Piece(s)


4.9 out of 5

You A-Maze Me Valentine Cards with Pencils

You A-Maze Me Valentine Cards with Pencils

IN-13674494

$16.99

24 Piece(s)

Mini Popcorn Bags in Valentine Treat Boxes

Mini Popcorn Bags in Valentine Treat Boxes

IN-32/675

$12.50

Per Dozen


4.1 out of 5

Valentine Truck M&M’s®

Valentine Truck M&M’s®

IN-13674566

$9.99 $7.48

24 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Show: