Your cart is currently empty.
Items remain in your shopping cart for 30 days.

Subtotal $0.00
110% Lowest Price Guarantee

Nostalgic Candy

(58 total)

Find old-fashioned candy favorites including candy sticks, rock candy, name brand candy and retro candy.

Sort Results By:
 
Show:
Stretchable Candy Bracelets

Stretchable Candy Bracelets

IN-5/916

$9.25 $6.98

48 Piece(s)


4.4 out of 5

Tootsie Roll® Candies

Tootsie Roll® Candies

IN-/K1087

$8.99

360 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Tootsie Roll® Miniature Pops®

Tootsie Roll® Miniature Pops®

IN-/K1599

$9.99

200 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Smarties® Roll Candies

Smarties® Roll Candies

IN-/K26

$8.75

120 Piece(s)


4.9 out of 5

Twizzlers® Licorice

Twizzlers® Licorice

IN-/K291

$12.99

180 Piece(s)


4.7 out of 5

Giant Pixy Stix®

Giant Pixy Stix®

IN-/K2134

$24.99

85 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Bulk Pixy Stix®

Bulk Pixy Stix®

IN-/K1944

$7.25

144 Piece(s)


4.7 out of 5

Machine-Size Gumballs

Machine-Size Gumballs

IN-/K70

$5.70

257 Piece(s)


3.5 out of 5

Dum Dum® Pops

Dum Dum® Pops

IN-/K68

$9.99

120 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Old-Fashioned Candy Sticks

Old-Fashioned Candy Sticks

IN-/K79

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


3.6 out of 5

Kid's Combo Candy Mix

Kid's Combo Candy Mix

IN-/K1398

$18.99

208 Piece(s)


3.5 out of 5

PEZ® Avengers 2™ Assortment

PEZ® Avengers 2™ Assortment

IN-13694778

$19.75

Per Dozen

Pop Rocks®

Pop Rocks®

IN-/K289

$9.50

Per Dozen


4.2 out of 5

PEZ® Despicable Me™ Assortments

PEZ® Despicable Me™ Assortments

IN-13694775

$19.75

Per Dozen


5.0 out of 5

Gumball Machine Toy Banks With Gum

Gumball Machine Toy Banks With Gum

IN-/K2190

$3.10

1 Set(s)


4.8 out of 5

Tootsie Roll® Child's Play® Assortment

Tootsie Roll® Child's Play® Assortment

IN-/K325

$15.99

138 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Wonka® Lik-m-aid® Fun Dip™ Candy

Wonka® Lik-m-aid® Fun Dip™ Candy

IN-/K142

$9.50

48 Piece(s)


4.9 out of 5

Candy-Filled Straws

Candy-Filled Straws

IN-/K18

$7.99

240 Piece(s)


4.4 out of 5

Stretchable Candy Necklaces

Stretchable Candy Necklaces

IN-5/923

$7.50

24 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Blue Candy Sticks

Blue Candy Sticks

IN-/K2100

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


3.7 out of 5

Ferrara Pan® Lemonhead® & Friends Variety Pack

Ferrara Pan® Lemonhead® & Friends Variety Pack

IN-/K1389

$12.75 $10.98

64 Piece(s)


3.3 out of 5

Crystal Rock Candy Pops

Crystal Rock Candy Pops

IN-/K800

$12.99

Per Dozen


4.0 out of 5

Tootsie® Pops

Tootsie® Pops

IN-/K19450

$18.99

100 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Candy Halloween Charm Bracelets

Candy Halloween Charm Bracelets

IN-25/3421

$9.25

48 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Saf-T-Pops®

Saf-T-Pops®

IN-/K2112

$11.50

60 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Black Candy Sticks

Black Candy Sticks

IN-/K2096

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Patriotic Candy Sticks

Patriotic Candy Sticks

IN-13640813

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Wonka® Mega Chewy Favorites

Wonka® Mega Chewy Favorites

IN-/K1861

$16.50

165 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Dubble Bubble® Gumballs

Dubble Bubble® Gumballs

IN-13676742

$12.50

680 Piece(s)


3.3 out of 5

Halloween Popcorn Balls

Halloween Popcorn Balls

IN-13672614

$9.99

Per Dozen

Purple Candy Sticks

Purple Candy Sticks

IN-/K2099

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Tootsie Roll® Mega Mix

Tootsie Roll® Mega Mix

IN-/K1567

$12.75

260 Piece(s)


4.9 out of 5

Nostalgic Candy Assortment

Nostalgic Candy Assortment

IN-13683310

$26.99

5 lb(s)


4.0 out of 5

Halloween Sixlets®

Halloween Sixlets®

IN-13711211

$9.99

110 Piece(s)

Stretchable Candy Cross Bracelets

Stretchable Candy Cross Bracelets

IN-5/228

$3.99

Per Dozen


4.8 out of 5

Jelly Belly® Mini Packs

Jelly Belly® Mini Packs

IN-/K1865

$13.99

36 Piece(s)


4.1 out of 5

Fall Sunflower Seed Packs

Fall Sunflower Seed Packs

IN-13656851

$12.00

24 Piece(s)


5.0 out of 5

Wax Bottles

Wax Bottles

IN-/K231

$7.99

50 Piece(s)


4.6 out of 5

Tootsie® Caramel Apple Suckers

Tootsie® Caramel Apple Suckers

IN-/K1565

$5.75

24 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Lemon Candy Bracelets

Lemon Candy Bracelets

IN-13695059

$3.99

Per Dozen


5.0 out of 5

White Candy Sticks

White Candy Sticks

IN-/K2106

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Yellow Candy Sticks

Yellow Candy Sticks

IN-/K2108

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Light Pink Candy Sticks

Light Pink Candy Sticks

IN-/K2104

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.2 out of 5

Crayola® Color Your Mouth Pops

Crayola® Color Your Mouth Pops

IN-13672519

$2.99

30 Piece(s)


3.3 out of 5

Red Candy Sticks

Red Candy Sticks

IN-/K2107

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Pink & Purple Assorted Candy Sticks

Pink & Purple Assorted Candy Sticks

IN-32/843

$13.00 $6.78

80 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Green Candy Sticks

Green Candy Sticks

IN-/K2109

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Light Blue Candy Sticks

Light Blue Candy Sticks

IN-/K2101

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Valentine Message in A Bottle with Candy Powder

Valentine Message in A Bottle with Candy Powder

IN-32/862

$8.50

Per Dozen


4.3 out of 5

Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

Sweethearts® Valentine Candy

IN-/K9

$15.99

36 Piece(s)


4.3 out of 5

Red Round Suckers

Red Round Suckers

IN-13698114

$9.99

67 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Lime Green Candy Sticks

Lime Green Candy Sticks

IN-/K2102

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.8 out of 5

Dum-Dums® Holiday Pops

Dum-Dums® Holiday Pops

IN-13676732

$3.99

40 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Green Round Suckers

Green Round Suckers

IN-13698117

$9.99

67 Piece(s)

Stretchable Heart-Shaped Valentine Candy Necklaces

Stretchable Heart-Shaped Valentine Candy Necklaces

IN-32/144

$7.50

24 Piece(s)


3.8 out of 5

Hot Pink Candy Sticks

Hot Pink Candy Sticks

IN-/K2105

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.5 out of 5

Orange Candy Sticks

Orange Candy Sticks

IN-/K2103

$15.50

80 Piece(s)


4.0 out of 5

Stretchable Heart-Shaped Valentine Candy Bracelets

Stretchable Heart-Shaped Valentine Candy Bracelets

IN-32/145

$9.25

48 Piece(s)


3.5 out of 5

Show: