Oriental Trading
MindWare
Fun365
CART
Search
1-800-875-8480
Live Chat
Help
Party Supplies
Holidays & Events
Toys & Games
Crafts
Teaching Supplies
Wedding
Religion & Faith
Personalized
Graduation
Sale
Limited Time!
Free Shipping
On Orders $49+
Applied
Click to Apply
Toys, Games & Novelties
Novelty Toys
Plush Toys
Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Religious
Heart
Skip Left Nav
Hide
Show
Special Offers
Clearance
(2)
Sale
(16)
Hide
Show
New Arrivals
New
(7)
Hide
Show
Bulk Assortments
Bulk
(31)
Hide
Show
Customer Rating
(42)
(66)
(66)
Hide
Show
Price
$5.01 - $10.00
(4)
$10.01 - $20.00
(37)
$20.01 - $50.00
(32)
Over $50.00
(18)
Hide
Show
Color
Assorted Colors
(7)
Blue
(1)
Brown
(1)
Grey
(1)
Multicolor
(18)
Orange
(1)
Pink
(2)
Red
(2)
White
(5)
Yellow
(1)
Load More...
Hide
Show
Occasion
Advent
(1)
Baby Shower
(1)
Everyday
(1)
Summer Camp
(9)
VBS
(14)
Hide
Show
Holidays
Christmas
(24)
Easter
(16)
Fourth of July
(1)
Grandparent's Day
(1)
Halloween
(4)
Hanukkah
(1)
Memorial Day
(1)
Mother's Day
(2)
Rosh Hashanah
(1)
Thanksgiving
(2)
Valentine's Day
(34)
Load More...
Hide
Show
Material
Fabric
(15)
Felt
(1)
Plastic
(1)
Polyester
(1)
Hide
Show
Personalized Products
Personalizable
(3)
Hide
Show
Theme
2023
(1)
2024
(1)
50s
(1)
60s
(1)
70s
(1)
80s
(34)
90s
(7)
Alien
(2)
Alligator
(6)
Angel
(1)
Animal
(507)
Anime
(51)
Apple
(2)
Arctic
(4)
Astronaut
(1)
Awesome Adventure
(1)
Bat
(14)
Beach
(7)
Bear
(116)
Bee
(1)
Bible Studies
(4)
Bird
(19)
Books
(10)
Buffalo Plaid
(1)
Bugs & Butterflies
(8)
Bunny
(59)
Butterfly
(1)
Cactus
(1)
Camp
(7)
Cardinal
(1)
Career
(2)
Casino Night
(1)
Cat
(129)
Celebrities
(1)
Chick
(11)
Christmas Tree
(4)
Circus
(2)
Classroom
(79)
Clown
(8)
Coffee
(1)
Comic Book
(40)
Country
(1)
County Fair
(1)
Cowboy
(4)
Cowgirl
(4)
Cupcake Party
(1)
Devil
(1)
Dinosaur
(26)
Doctor
(1)
Dog
(61)
Dolphin
(3)
Donut
(4)
Dragon
(4)
Dress Up
(1)
Duck
(2)
Egg
(8)
Elephant
(13)
Elf
(10)
Emoji
(6)
Fairytale & Storybook
(2)
Fantasy
(57)
Farm
(16)
Fiesta
(3)
Firefighter
(4)
Flamingo
(5)
Flower
(1)
Food
(20)
Food & Beverage
(45)
Frogs & Turtles
(10)
Funny
(26)
Garden
(2)
Ghost
(24)
Gingerbread
(8)
Glamping
(1)
Gnome
(4)
Gorilla
(2)
Gothic
(2)
Halloween Carnival
(7)
Haunted Mansion
(1)
He Lives
(2)
Heart
(27)
Horror
(44)
Horse
(4)
Irish
(2)
Jack-o-lantern
(22)
Jungle
(24)
Knight
(1)
Leaf
(1)
Legend
(4)
Lion
(10)
Llama
(6)
Love
(5)
Luau
(11)
Manga
(7)
Mermaid
(3)
Monkey
(28)
Monster
(55)
Mummy
(1)
Narwhal
(9)
Nativity
(13)
Nordic Noel
(1)
Nutcracker
(1)
Outback
(3)
Outer space
(18)
Owl
(7)
Pajama Crew
(3)
Panda
(11)
Patriotic
(15)
Penguin
(21)
Pets
(102)
Pineapple
(2)
Pirate
(2)
Police
(4)
Political
(1)
Pool Party
(1)
Pop Culture
(31)
Popstar
(2)
Princess
(1)
Pumpkin
(17)
Rainbow
(5)
Reindeer
(22)
Religious
(65)
Reptile
(14)
Reward
(13)
Rocky Beach
(2)
Roman & Greek
(1)
Safari
(17)
Santa
(11)
Scarecrow
(2)
Scary
(43)
Scary Clown
(8)
Sci-Fi
(105)
Sea Life
(45)
Sensory
(19)
Shamrock
(1)
Shark
(12)
Skulls and Skeletons
(12)
Slumber Party
(3)
Smile Face
(2)
Snowflake
(2)
Snowman
(18)
Sock Monkey
(1)
Southwest
(2)
Southwestern
(3)
Spider
(1)
Spirit of the Seas
(2)
Spookadelic
(1)
Sports
(72)
Star Student
(3)
Strawberry
(1)
Superhero
(31)
The Highest Power
(1)
Tiger
(1)
Tropical
(11)
Turkey
(5)
TV & Movie
(466)
Unicorn
(38)
Vampire
(9)
Video Game
(241)
Villains
(33)
Vintage
(1)
Werewolf
(1)
Western
(4)
Wild Encounters
(16)
Winter Wonderland
(1)
Witch
(13)
Zombie
(10)
Zoo Animal
(28)
Load More...
Hide
Show
Brand
Oriental Trading
(83)
Hide
Show
Grade
Preschool
(7)
Kindergarten
(7)
Hide
Show
Size
Mini
(18)
Hide
Show
Season
Fall
(6)
Winter
(5)
Hide
Show
For Whom
Adults
(2)
Boys
(9)
For Her
(2)
Girls
(9)
Kids
(9)
Teens
(1)
Hide
Show
Exclusive
Exclusive Items
(76)
Hide
Show
Popular Collections
Assortment Kits
(2)
Cheer Bags
(23)
Gifts
(8)
Individually Wrapped
(1)
Party Favors
(79)
Stocking Stuffers
(29)
Hide
Show
Faith Based Event
Catholic Schools Week
(1)
Childrens Ministries
(15)
Church Festivals
(1)
Jump to Top of List
Plush Toys
by
"Religious"
and "Heart"
(91 items)
Sort by
Recommended
Best Selling
Average Customer Rating
Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Submit
Religious Jesus Loves You Hearts Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#36/382
$
19.99
(38)
Quick View
Valentine Red & Silver Reversible Sequin Stuffed Hearts - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13784197
$
19.99
(23)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Stuffed Kangaroos with Heart Pouch - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13784195
$
27.99
(11)
Quick View
Valentine Stuffed Frogs with Pink Heart - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13757240
$
24.99
(11)
Quick View
Bear Hugs Heart Brown Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/1577
$
19.99
(2)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Hearts with Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13756410
$
20.69
(21)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Red Pocket Hearts Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/150
$
22.99
(17)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Stuffed Conversation Hearts - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13718824
$
22.99
(16)
Quick View
Halloween Stuffed Conversation Hearts - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#14113921
$
19.99
Quick View
Valentine's Day Pastel Hearts Stuffed Teddy Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/233
$
19.99
(17)
Quick View
Valentine’s Day Pink & Purple Heart Print Stuffed Dogs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/1579
$
27.99
(69)
Quick View
Easter Stuffed Colorful Jelly Beans with Prayer Card - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13757458
$
17.98
was
$
24.99
(6)
Quick View
Stuffed Jesus with Sash
1 Piece(s)
#13785952
$
7.79
(87)
Quick View
Mini Religious Lamb of God T-Shirts Stuffed Lambs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#36/1443
$
19.99
(46)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Spring Stuffed Animal Assortment
50 Piece(s)
#13962096
$
42.98
was
$
57.99
(10)
Quick View
Prayer Stuffed Bears with Prayer Card - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#36/1196
$
19.99
(66)
Quick View
4 1/4" Jesus Loves You Beary Much Stuffed Bear-Filled Easter Eggs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13962047
$
13.98
was
$
19.99
(4)
Quick View
Bulk Prayer Stuffed Starfish with Prayer Card - 50 Pc.
50 Piece(s)
#14279172
$
44.98
was
$
52.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Mini Bible Verse Stuffed Animal Assortment
48 Piece(s)
#13658573
$
57.99
(40)
Quick View
Wild About Jesus Stuffed Safari Animals - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#12/4452
$
29.99
(19)
Quick View
Religious Rainbow-Colored Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#36/523
$
19.99
(61)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Outer Space VBS Stuffed Character Assortment
50 Piece(s)
#14239531
$
44.97
was
$
54.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Food Pun Avocado Taco Pizza Stuffed Characters
50 Piece(s)
#14114923
$
57.99
Quick View
New Life in Jesus Stuffed Butterflies with Story - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13820383
$
24.99
(15)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Flat Stuffed Monster Assortment
50 Piece(s)
#14279158
$
57.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Camp VBS Stuffed Flat Characters
50 Piece(s)
#14383968
$
44.98
was
$
54.99
Quick View
Valentine’s Day T-Shirt Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13756487
$
19.99
(18)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Donut Worry Pray Stuffed Donuts
50 Piece(s)
#14279165
$
44.98
was
$
52.99
Quick View
Religious Stuffed Snowmen - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13779215
$
19.99
(37)
Quick View
40" Large Stuffed Jesus with Sash
1 Piece(s)
#14279067
$
49.99
Quick View
Mini Plush Pope Character Toys - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13808796
$
12.97
was
$
18.59
(2)
Quick View
Christmas Nativity Stuffed Mary with Baby Jesus
1 Piece(s)
#14148504
$
12.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Winter Animal Stuffed Toy Assortment
50 Unit(s)
#14148586
$
57.99
Quick View
Stuffed Pumpkin Pass the Blessings Games - 12 Pc.
12 Piece(s)
#14114926
$
19.99
(5)
Quick View
Pageant Stuffed Baby Jesus
1 Piece(s)
#13750361
$
12.99
(18)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Jesus Loves Me Stuffed Animal Assortment
50 Piece(s)
#13911708
$
57.99
(60)
Quick View
Religious Embroidered Stuffed Lambs of God - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#36/1444
$
19.99
(29)
Quick View
Mini Arctic Friends Stuffed Animal Assortment - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s)
#6/1723
$
32.99
(18)
Quick View
Apple of God’s Eye Plush with Card for 12
12 Piece(s)
#14114929
$
27.99
Quick View
Felt Jesus-Shaped Handouts - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s)
#14352842
$
21.99
Quick View
Jesus Loves You Stuffed Bear Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen
#14148527
$
17.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Prayer Stuffed Animals
50 Piece(s)
#14279171
$
52.99
Quick View
Personalized Valentine T-Shirt Brown Stuffed Bear
Each
#32/1208
$
12.99
(40)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Hugging Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/194
$
39.99
(10)
Quick View
Valentine’s Day Bendable Stuffed Red Roses with Card - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/473
$
19.99
(19)
Quick View
Mini Nativity Stuffed Character Set
1 Set(s)
#13752154
$
19.99
(6)
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Huggers Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/146
$
19.99
(15)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Hanukkah Stuffed Animal Assortment
50 Piece(s)
#13957841
$
57.99
Quick View
Glad Tidings Angel with Book & Kindness Challenge Cards - 28 Pc.
28 Piece(s)
#13957865
$
19.99
Quick View
Valentine Stuffed Snakes - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/775
$
27.99
(27)
Quick View
Stuffed Dog with Lollipop Valentine Exchanges for 12
Per Dozen
#13718296
$
29.98
was
$
37.99
(25)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Winter Scarf Stuffed Angel Assortment
50 Unit(s)
#14148501
$
57.99
Quick View
Valentine's Day White Stuffed Lion
1 Piece(s)
#13599572
$
5.79
(31)
Quick View
Personalized Faith Stuffed Bear with T-Shirt - Pink
1 Piece(s)
#14207439
$
14.99
Quick View
Bulk 72 Pc. Mini Valentine's Day Hugs & Kisses Stuffed Bears
72 Piece(s)
#13958434
$
109.99
Save 8%
(2)
Quick View
Religious Stuffed Thankful for Turkeys with Card - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#14279180
$
19.99
Quick View
Valentine Long Arm Stuffed Animals - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#13718837
$
19.99
(20)
Quick View
Stuffed Smitten with Jesus Plush - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#14092346
$
11.97
was
$
12.99
(2)
Quick View
Valentine Long Arm Stuffed Gorillas - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen
#32/586
$
19.99
(34)
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Fall Stuffed Characters
50 Piece(s)
#14115037
$
52.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Religious Patriotic Stuffed Characters
50 Piece(s)
#14239278
$
57.99
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. Mini Religious Halloween Plush Characters
50 Piece(s)
#14114922
$
47.99
(8)
Quick View
Religious Fall Stuffed Character Handouts with Card for 50
56 Piece(s)
#14293436
$
47.99
Quick View
Personalized Faith Stuffed Bear with T-Shirt - Blue
1 Piece(s)
#14207440
$
14.99
Quick View
1
2
Submit