All content on this site is available, via phone, Monday to Friday from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM CST or Saturday and Sunday from 7:00 AM to 10:00 PM CST at
If you experience any accessibility issues, please contact us.
Legend of the Christmas Stuffed Donkey with Card - 12 Pc.
Mini Plush Baby Jesus Handouts with Card
Scented Happy Birthday Jesus Cupcake Slow-Rising Squishies
Happy Birthday Jesus Clappers
Donkey Bendables with Card
Nativity Finger Puppets
Candy Cane Religious Stuffed Bears with Card - 12 Pc.
Nativity Puzzle Cubes
Plush Religious Snowmen
Nesting Nativity Playset
Christmas Stuffed Lamb with Card
Mini Nativity Story Cameras
Nativity Spin Tops
Jesus Candy Cane Stress Toys
Mini Arctic Friends Stuffed Animal Assortment
Nativity Rubber Duckies
Round Stuffed Nativity Animals
Happy Birthday Jesus Push-Up Pom-Pom Poppers
Pageant Plush Baby Jesus
Three Kings Pull-Back Toys
Mini Pocket Nativity Scenes
Religious Stuffed Penguins
Long Arm Stuffed Nativity Animals
Candy Cane Religious Stuffed Bears with Card - 48 Pc.
“Happy Birthday Jesus!” Novelty Assortment
Stuffed Bears with Jingle with Joy for Jesus Shirts
Bulk Long Arm Stuffed Nativity Animals - 72 Pc.
Happy Birthday Jesus Wrist Whistles
Legend of the Christmas Stuffed Donkey with Card - 48 Pc.
Manger Minis Surprise Blind Bags
Angel Pull-Back Toys
Angel Hand Clappers
Happy Birthday Jesus Rubber Duckies
Cross Printed Fidget Spinners
Religious Christmas Plush Toy Assortment
Rainbow Faith Stuffed Bears
Holy Family Heart-Shaped Plush
Long Arm Plush Angels
Angel Slow-Rising Squishies
Bulk Religious Novelty Assortment - 250 Pc.
Religious Treasure Chest Assortment
Mini Nativity Tambourines
Hugging Plush Angel Slap Bracelets
Life of Jesus Nesting Dolls
12 Days of Christmas Nativity Toy Advent Calendars
Stuffed Religious Husky Dogs with Candy Cane
Religious Glittering Plush Stars
Nativity Blocks Play Set
Donkey Pull-Back Toys with Card
Angel Stuffed Bears
Lamb Slow-Rising Scented Squishies
Bulk Long Arm Plush Angels - 72 Pc.
Foam Nativity Play Set
Legend Stuffed Donkey with Card
Personalized Religious Christmas Mini Slime Assortment
Are you looking for religious Christmas novelty toys? You've come to the right place! Our selection of praise-worthy picks are not only perfectly priced, but also full of fun. Whether you're shopping for Sunday School supplies or religious stocking stuffers, don't wait to stock up on our awesome assortments and save on great giveaways!
The holidays are for gathering, giving and celebrating the reason of the season. So, why start the celebrating with big savings on fun religious toys? Shop our huge selection of stress toys, plush toys, finger puppets, bubble bottles and more. Each item in our curated collection is designed to not only bring the fun, but also remind children the importance of the reason of the Christmas season and to always keep Him in their hearts. If you're looking for Sunday School giveaways to handout to children around Christmas, our Mega Religious Novelty Assortment is a merry must-have. This popular assortment features all sorts of religious handouts kids will love. Add this assortment to your Sunday School supplies and hand items out at Sunday School, VBS or use them for a church carnival!
Are you looking for adorably affordable stocking stuffers? Give our Plush Rainbow Faith Bears a try. Featuring vibrant hues and a cross symbol stitched into each bear's chest, these cute and cuddly bears make for a meaningful Christmas gift! Another friendly reminder of faith children will love is our Nativity Finger Puppets. These mini characters are an entertaining and inspiring way to help kids learn about the Christmas story! Stock up on these, then hand them out to each Sunday School student after a lesson on the meaning of Christmas.
While you're on our site, don't forget to shop around for more faith-filled fun finds. Our selection and variety offers a little something for every taste and budget, no matter your event or occasion. Plus, we've got a lot of exclusive VBS themes you should explore! And at our prices, you'll be able to have more faith-filled fun for less. After all, it's our job to help make the world more fun!