Customer Reviews
21 Reviews

4.7/5.0
21 Reviews
  • 5 Star 76.00% of all ratings 16
  • 4 Star 14.00% of all ratings 3
  • 3 Star 10.00% of all ratings 2
  • 2 Star 0% of all ratings 0
  • 1 Star 0% of all ratings 0
PhxGirl
October 27, 2014 – www.phoenixchildren.org
great prize to win
every year we purchase these for our annual halloween party. the children love them and try to win one for every finger. worth the money and are decent quality.
StMaryLibrary
August 30, 2014 – Escondido
Huge hit!
These witches fingers have been a hit year after year in my library. I give them out to the K thru 3rd graders to use as 'reading fingers'. Works great for beginning readers! Then on their way back to class, we use them as 'shush fingers'!
September 02, 2020 – GRAFTON
Ghoulishly FUN!
These are Not cheap plastic, they are a Better Quality Rubbery textured sort of thing. FUN, FUN, FUN.....EVERYONE Wanted these...EVEN THE “ADULTS”.......hmmm.....I will have to buy more : )
October 04, 2021
Cute, but horrible moth ball smell.
These are really cute and good quality, but they smell horrible! A really strong moth ball smell! I have put them outside to air out and I've tried baking soda and vinegar, but nothing works. The smell is just as strong. I was going to hand these out in treat bags for Halloween, but not sure I want to anymore due to the strong smell. Super bummed.
Oriental Trading
October 07, 2021
Staff
Hello! Thanks for your review. We're sorry that our Glow-in-the-Dark Martian Fingers didn't work out for you. We're committed to delivering fun, safe and affordable products, and we'll try to address the issues you brought up. Please call our Customer Care Center at 1-800-228-2269 for a full refund or an easy exchange. Thanks for bringing this to our attention!
Krishelle H.
October 10, 2019 – MAPLETON
awesome but nail polish comes right off
love these but the nail polish comes off pretty easily. It's not a big deal because it still has a stain of red on the nail but the fingers look so much better with the nail polish on.
Liked: Quality,Value,Fun
November 01, 2025
A surprise box favorite!
My students have always loved these! Some collect one every time they earn a surprise. ☺️
Liked: Quality,Value,Fun
See All Reviews