Customer Reviews
612 Reviews

4.2/5.0
612 Reviews
  • 5 Star 65.00% of all ratings 399
  • 4 Star 10.00% of all ratings 62
  • 3 Star 10.00% of all ratings 62
  • 2 Star 6.00% of all ratings 34
  • 1 Star 9.00% of all ratings 55

Customer Images

See All Customer Images
August 31, 2021
Verified Purchaser
Color of pencils was off
The color wasn’t Aqua that I requested. I purposely ordered the aqua color and instead got another shade of blue.
July 15, 2021
I'm VERY disappointed.
Liked the bright red finish, and the crisp, clear lettering. DISLIKEs: (1) the "lead/graphite" core is NOT in the center of the wooden sheath of the pencil. This error reflects is a VERY poor quality control in the 'manufacturing' process, and results in uneven and too-frequent sharpening. It makes for a very non-aesthetic writing instrument. (2) Another DISLIKE is that the lead itself is too "hard" resulting in VERY light impressions when writing.
Liked: Fun
Disliked: Quality,Value
Oriental Trading
July 20, 2021
Staff
Hello! Thanks for your comments on the customization of our Personalized Red Pencils. We're always striving to improve our personalized products, and your review lets us know that we still have areas to improve on. Thank you for bringing it to our attention! Please give our Customer Care Center a ring at 1-800-228-2269 for a no-hassle exchange or a refund.
May 06, 2024
Watch color
The actual pencil color is more blue than purple. We wanted them to look like KSU royal purple.
October 11, 2022
Much improved from 6 years ago!
Six years ago, I bought a gross (12 dozen/144 pencils) in 12 different colors. They were fun and the students liked them but I thought they were difficult to read and some carvings looked better than others. Fast forward to today. I ordered 4 sets, instead, to see if they improved at all. I'm happy to say that the letters are much easier to read! I haven't given them away, yet. I'm waiting for Christmas. So, I don't know, yet, about the quality. But they do look nice!!!
Liked: Quality,Value,Fun
Linda S.
April 12, 2024
Just OK
They are OK, but not 100% what I expected. The photo showed I would receive purple pencils with purple erasers, but instead, the erasers on the pencils I received were white. In addition, the purple color wasn't as bright as shown in the product photo. I was disappointed.
September 29, 2022
Keepsake pencil
Great value, worked well for our event and the kids loved them!
Liked: Quality,Value,Fun
See All Reviews