Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Skip Left Nav
Jump to Top of List

Stocking Stuffers Under $5 - Toys & Novelty Gifts

(70 items)
4" x 4" 3D-Printed Collapsable Christmas Tree Plastic Fidget Toy
4" x 4" 3D-Printed Collapsable Christmas Tree Plastic Fidget Toy
1 Piece(s) #14590997
$4.99
 
 
Quick View
2 1/2" Mini Holiday Characters Plastic Slide Puzzles - 12 Pc.
2 1/2" Mini Holiday Characters Plastic Slide Puzzles - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #4/4570
On
Sale
$2.98
46% OFF
(19)
 
 
Quick View
2 1/2" Mini Happy Birthday Jesus Plastic Slide Puzzles - 24 Pc.
2 1/2" Mini Happy Birthday Jesus Plastic Slide Puzzles - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #36/13540
$4.98
(13)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Christmas Elf Red, Green & White Vinyl Finger Flingers - 12 Pc.
3 1/2" Christmas Elf Red, Green & White Vinyl Finger Flingers - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #4/5523
$2.98
(14)
 
 
Quick View
6 1/2" Mini Happy Birthday Jesus Cardboard Jijgsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
6 1/2" Mini Happy Birthday Jesus Cardboard Jijgsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
Per Dozen #4/4569
On
Sale
$4.98
40% OFF
(45)
 
 
Quick View
5" x 4 1/4" Mini Peanuts® Christmas Inspirational Cardboard Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
5" x 4 1/4" Mini Peanuts® Christmas Inspirational Cardboard Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
Per Dozen #13715684
$4.98
(17)
 
 
Quick View
Nativity YoYos
Nativity YoYos
Per Dozen #13957870
$4.98
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer® Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
Mini Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer® Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
Per Dozen #13957029
$4.98
(3)
 
 
Quick View
2 1/4" Classic Holiday Swirl Plastic Spin Tops - 12 Pc.
2 1/4" Classic Holiday Swirl Plastic Spin Tops - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #4/3707
$4.98
(19)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Christmas Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
Mini Christmas Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #4/5164
$3.98
(6)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/4" Mini Holiday Red, Green & Blue Plastic Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
1 1/4" Mini Holiday Red, Green & Blue Plastic Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13957041
$3.98
 
 
Quick View
5" x 6 1/2" Mini Snow Buddies Christmas Cardboard Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
5" x 6 1/2" Mini Snow Buddies Christmas Cardboard Jigsaw Puzzles - 12 Boxes
Per Dozen #4/5457
$4.98
(13)
 
 
Quick View
6" x 7" Nativity Christmas Cardboard Bingo Game for 16
6" x 7" Nativity Christmas Cardboard Bingo Game for 16
1 Set(s) #4/8062
$4.98
(24)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Metallic Snowflake YoYos - 12 Pc.
Mini Metallic Snowflake YoYos - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #4/4933
$4.79
(18)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Flying Discs - 12 Pc.
Mini Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Flying Discs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13910464
$4.98
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14133412
$4.98
 
 
Quick View
2 3/4" x 4 1/4" Christmas Jokes Paper Scratch-Off Cards - 24 Pc.
2 3/4" x 4 1/4" Christmas Jokes Paper Scratch-Off Cards - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14090903
$4.98
(12)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Foam Dice - 12 Pc.
Mini Dr. Seuss™ The Grinch Foam Dice - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14133399
$4.98
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Frosty the Snowman™ Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
Frosty the Snowman™ Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14328092
$4.98
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Chipboard Nativity Playset
Chipboard Nativity Playset
1 Set(s) #13713265
$4.98
(15)
 
 
Quick View
Christmas Nativity Stuffed Mary with Baby Jesus
Christmas Nativity Stuffed Mary with Baby Jesus
1 Piece(s) #14148504
$4.98
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Buddy the Elf™ Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
Buddy the Elf™ Disc Shooters - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14328032
$4.98
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Expressions® Christmas Present Scented Slow-Rise Squishy
Expressions® Christmas Present Scented Slow-Rise Squishy
1 Piece(s) #13819251
Clearance
Price
$3.77
54% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Expressions® Christmas Mermaid Scented Slow-Rise Squishy
Expressions® Christmas Mermaid Scented Slow-Rise Squishy
1 Piece(s) #13819246
Clearance
Price
$4.17
49% OFF
(2)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/4" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Christmas Santa & Reindeer Plastic Spin Tops
1 1/4" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Christmas Santa & Reindeer Plastic Spin Tops
48 Piece(s) #13713044
$4.98
(6)
 
 
Quick View
1/4" x 1/2" Bulk 50 Pc. Bright Color 3D-Printed Micro Rubber Duck Plastic Toys
1/4" x 1/2" Bulk 50 Pc. Bright Color 3D-Printed Micro Rubber Duck Plastic Toys
50 Piece(s) #14584283
$4.99
 
 
Quick View
2 3/4" x 4" Dr. Seuss™ Oh the Places You’ll Go!™ Foam Gliders - 12 Pc.
2 3/4" x 4" Dr. Seuss™ Oh the Places You’ll Go!™ Foam Gliders - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14511940
$2.29
 
 
Quick View
3/4" x 1 1/4" Bright Color 3D-Printed Rubber Duck Toys - 6 Pc.
3/4" x 1 1/4" Bright Color 3D-Printed Rubber Duck Toys - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #14584285
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
2" Silly Monster Blue, Green & Red Rubber Ducks - 12 Pc.
2" Silly Monster Blue, Green & Red Rubber Ducks - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #25/5988
On
Sale
$4.98
50% OFF
(60)
 
 
Quick View
2 1/4" Fast Food Pizza, Burger & Fries Plastic Maze Puzzles - 12 Pc.
2 1/4" Fast Food Pizza, Burger & Fries Plastic Maze Puzzles - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14469299
On
Sale
$4.48
18% OFF
 
 
Quick View
1" (25mm) Neon Colors Ball & Jacks Classic Party Games - 6 Sets
1" (25mm) Neon Colors Ball & Jacks Classic Party Games - 6 Sets
6 Piece(s) #14472556
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
Religious Simple Sayings Sticker Roll - 100 Pc.
Religious Simple Sayings Sticker Roll - 100 Pc.
1 Roll(s) #14114989
$4.79
(5)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Mini S'more Character Plastic Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
1 1/2" Mini S'more Character Plastic Magic Springs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14552811
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
3 1/4" Classic 54-Card Decks of Cardstock Playing Cards - 3 Pc.
3 1/4" Classic 54-Card Decks of Cardstock Playing Cards - 3 Pc.
3 Piece(s) #14471903
$3.79
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Neon Colored Plastic Compasses on a Nylon Cord - 6 Pc.
1 1/2" Neon Colored Plastic Compasses on a Nylon Cord - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #14472555
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
2" Mini Solid Color Pull-Back Plastic Monster Trucks - 4 Pc.
2" Mini Solid Color Pull-Back Plastic Monster Trucks - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14472539
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
2" Pink Ribbon Breast Cancer Awareness Rubber Ducks - 4 Pc.
2" Pink Ribbon Breast Cancer Awareness Rubber Ducks - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14472541
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
2" Smile Face Assorted Bright Colors Metal YoYos - 4 Pc.
2" Smile Face Assorted Bright Colors Metal YoYos - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14472538
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Mini Woodland Animal Rabbit, Mouse & Hedgehog Mochi Squishies - 4 Pc.
1 1/2" Mini Woodland Animal Rabbit, Mouse & Hedgehog Mochi Squishies - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14472548
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
1 3/4" – 2 3/4" Mini Insect Vinyl Finger Puppet Toys - 6 Pc.
1 3/4" – 2 3/4" Mini Insect Vinyl Finger Puppet Toys - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #14472553
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
Glow-in-the-Dark Space Force Badges - 12 Pc.
Glow-in-the-Dark Space Force Badges - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13843893
Clearance
Price
$3.87
59% OFF
 
 
Quick View
2" Bulk 144 Pc. Mini Bright Colors Plastic Jumping Frogs
2" Bulk 144 Pc. Mini Bright Colors Plastic Jumping Frogs
144 Piece(s) #39/14
On
Sale
$4.48
42% OFF
(36)
 
 
Quick View
8" Neon Plastic Beads Rainfall Tube Fidget Toy
8" Neon Plastic Beads Rainfall Tube Fidget Toy
1 Piece(s) #14474491
On
Sale
$3.78
16% OFF
 
 
Quick View
2" Nerf® Hand-Held Plastic Disc Shooters - 4 Pc.
2" Nerf® Hand-Held Plastic Disc Shooters - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #13826401
$3.99
(9)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem™ Mini Skateboards – 4 Pc.
3 1/2" Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem™ Mini Skateboards – 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14387043
$4.29
 
 
Quick View
Safari Arctic Fox Toy
Safari Arctic Fox Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240180
$3.93
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Wolf Pup Toy
Safari Wolf Pup Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239758
$3.92
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
2 1/2" - 3 1/4" Multicolored Plastic Puzzle Balls - 4 Pc.
2 1/2" - 3 1/4" Multicolored Plastic Puzzle Balls - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14472544
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
Safari Beaver Toy
Safari Beaver Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239815
$4.58
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Super-Sized 90s Fun Bands - 6 Pc.
Super-Sized 90s Fun Bands - 6 Pc.
36 Piece(s) #13955367
Clearance
Price
$3.37
60% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Soak & Splash Unicorn Bubble Gun
Soak & Splash Unicorn Bubble Gun
1 Piece(s) #14233975
On
Sale
$3.27
61% OFF
 
 
Quick View
DIY Blank Playing Cards with Plastic Box
DIY Blank Playing Cards with Plastic Box
1 Set(s) #13807952
$4.49
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Safari Kid Goat Toy
Safari Kid Goat Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240156
$4.49
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Red,eyed Tree Frog Toy
Safari Red,eyed Tree Frog Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240017
$3.93
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Rabbit Toy
Safari Rabbit Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240004
$3.86
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Chicken Toy
Safari Chicken Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240198
$3.53
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Piglet Toy
Safari Piglet Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239638
$2.74
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Coyote Pup Toy
Safari Coyote Pup Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239677
$4.58
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Cheetah Cub Toy
Safari Cheetah Cub Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239719
$4.99
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Black Bear Cub Toy
Safari Black Bear Cub Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239670
$3.93
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Slow-Rising Strawberry Shortcake Scented Squishy
Slow-Rising Strawberry Shortcake Scented Squishy
1 Piece(s) #13819043
$3.97
 
 
Quick View
Safari Platypus Toy
Safari Platypus Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240079
$4.99
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Dachshund Toy
Safari Dachshund Toy
1 Piece(s) #14239744
$4.99
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
Safari Tabby Cat Toy
Safari Tabby Cat Toy
1 Piece(s) #14240051
$3.53
Sold and Shipped by Safari Programs Inc
 
 
Quick View
1 2

Affordable Glow-in-the-Dark Toys & Mini Puzzles

Discover the perfect budget-friendly stocking stuffers with our curated $2-$5 range of toys and novelties. Our collection features popular glow-in-the-dark toys that captivate children's imaginations, along with compact mini puzzles that make excellent party favors or classroom rewards. With 82+ items including sensory fidget toys, character-themed novelties, and bulk-packaged games, you'll find diverse options for Christmas stockings, birthday goody bags, or everyday kids gifts. Oriental Trading's exclusive items combine quality with value, offering durable plastic compacts, stretchy rubber fidgets, and scented squishy toys that withstand hours of play. Enjoy bulk pricing advantages on these inexpensive Christmas toys while maintaining your budget - most items ship for free on orders over $25!