These boxes were a nightmare to assemble. They easily tore on the side putting them together and the only way it would stay together is if we taped them. I spent a lot of time getting them ready to fill. Not what I had expected at all.
mmum
December 07, 2018
– Catasauqua PA
Not worth buying
Not worth buying The boxes were much smaller than they appeared online. The sides do not want to stay in they will need to be taped
Greyhoundmom1
December 15, 2018
– Greyhoundmom1
Handy for cookies
Used these boxes to put homemade cookies in. They were attractive boxes and I liked the see through pane. They were however, a little small. Although measurements were given, it seemed smaller when I got them. They were easy to put together though and I used all of them for the cookies.
JaclynR
November 25, 2018
– West Chester, Ohio
Wonderful
I bought these for decorated pretzel rods, they are the ideal size!
Subaruba
December 30, 2017
– Laguna Beach
Colotful
The design & color are festive, I thought they would be larger but they're great for small gifts
NCS55
September 20, 2018
– IN
Cute and Practical for Gifts
These aren't just for cookies. use them for whatever you need to that will fit in here. Cover your gift with tissue paper and it won't show through the box.
NRyan8
December 13, 2016
Very nice, but smaller than indicated
These boxes are very nice, the colors are vibrant and as pictured. I used them for Christmas cookies, and was able to fit 9 3" cookies into each box. I was slightly concerned when I received them, because they are slightly smaller than described. The boxes are 3" wide, but only 2.5" tall, which meant that my cookies had to be slanted rather than stacked standing straight up. I used a small piece of tape to secure the ends as another reviewer mentioned, and they held together very nicely once closed.
December 18, 2022
Perfect for holiday gifting
Exactly as I expected - great size for gifting small treats. The colors are vibrant and festive, and the boxes are sturdy enough to stack a few for easy packing to deliver. I wouldn't want to do a ton of these since they're finicky and time consuming to fold, and the cardboard is pretty flimsy (there is a bit of a gap in the lid when assembled) but what else would you expect at this price point? They do their job.
December 23, 2025
size change
I have been buying this item for years and the size was perfect. I was so disappointed when they arrived this year, they were much smaller and didn't hold the usual number of cookies. The item number is the same, which gave no clue as to the size change. Please go back to the 8 x 3 size or offer something else in that size,
December 08, 2025
Measure correctly
Much smaller than displayed unable to use because photo is misleading
Liked:
Quality,Value,Fun
Oriental Trading
December 11, 2025
Staff
Hello! Thanks for your feedback on your Holiday Cookie Boxes. It seems the product description is missing some important information. We will get it updated. Please give us a call at 1-800-228-2269. Thanks for bringing this to our attention!
December 13, 2023
Holiday treat boxes
Both the cookie boxes and candy boxes have worked out perfectly for me. I made cookies and placed them inside
and I made several varieties of fudge and placed them in the other boxes.
The snowflake boxes didn't hold up as well with the fudge in them though when you attempted to close them because
they have to slide through the box for the cover. I had 3 of them that tore off the end of the box which wasn't nice.
But I had ordered enough that it still worked out
Liked:
Quality,Value,Fun
December 29, 2022
Cute boxes, fun colors
I am very happy with these boxes, they’re just the right size for when you want to pack up some full-size cookies or a bunch of smaller treats. The festive colors are fun, too. I did have to tape the sides of the box so they’d stand upright, but that’s not a dealer killer, it only took a second to add the tape.
