Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Skip Left Nav
Jump to Top of List

Top-Rated 4-Star Holiday Party Supplies

(1508 items)
Knitted Mitten Holiday Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Knitted Mitten Holiday Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14133187
$21.99
(2)
 
 
Quick View
1" x 2" Mini Transparent Pull-Back Cars - 12 Pc.
1" x 2" Mini Transparent Pull-Back Cars - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13627232
$10.99
(15)
 
 
Quick View
4 1/4" x 12" Red Mesh Christmas Stockings with Carry Strap - 10 Pc.
4 1/4" x 12" Red Mesh Christmas Stockings with Carry Strap - 10 Pc.
10 Piece(s) #4/16
$5.49
(54)
 
 
Quick View
Better Together First Grade Bracelet Handout Craft Kit – Makes 12
Better Together First Grade Bracelet Handout Craft Kit – Makes 12
Makes 12 #14422719
$10.99
 
 
Quick View
Sticker by Number Halloween Cards - 24 pc
Sticker by Number Halloween Cards - 24 pc
24 Piece(s) #13981283
$5.79
(3)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Bulk 360 Pc. Religious Temporary Tattoo Assortment
1 1/2" Bulk 360 Pc. Religious Temporary Tattoo Assortment
360 Piece(s) #13942953
$27.99
 
 
Quick View
Inflatable 11" Red & White Medium Beach Balls - 12 Pc.
Inflatable 11" Red & White Medium Beach Balls - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13940268
$13.49
 
 
Quick View
Mini Red Favor Boxes - 24 Pc.
Mini Red Favor Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #3/3604
$3.49
(48)
 
 
Quick View
4" Ice Skating Santa Claus Christmas Tree Ornaments - 12 Pc.
4" Ice Skating Santa Claus Christmas Tree Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14465282
$21.99
(2)
 
 
Quick View
1" Bulk 48 Pc. Micro Out-Of-This-World Vinyl Aliens
1" Bulk 48 Pc. Micro Out-Of-This-World Vinyl Aliens
48 Piece(s) #39/1172
$14.99
(23)
 
 
Quick View
2" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Multicolored Vinyl Finger Puppet Assortment
2" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Multicolored Vinyl Finger Puppet Assortment
48 Piece(s) #5/1624
$21.99
(52)
 
 
Quick View
2 1/4" x 3 1/4" Bulk Mini Dr. Seuss™ Book Covers Notepads
2 1/4" x 3 1/4" Bulk Mini Dr. Seuss™ Book Covers Notepads
48 Piece(s) #13678858
On
Sale
$25.98
16% OFF
(44)
 
 
Quick View
Red Wax Lips - 12 Pc.
Red Wax Lips - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #/K285
On
Sale
$24.98
27% OFF
(19)
 
 
Quick View
Dancing Nutcracker Pull-String Wood Christmas Ornaments - 6 Pc.
Dancing Nutcracker Pull-String Wood Christmas Ornaments - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #14133117
$32.99
(2)
 
 
Quick View
2" x 6" Bulk 48 Pc. Peanuts® Snoopy & Friends Double-Sided Bookmarks
2" x 6" Bulk 48 Pc. Peanuts® Snoopy & Friends Double-Sided Bookmarks
48 Piece(s) #14363326
$9.99
 
 
Quick View
Heart-Shaped Swirl Lollipops - 12 Pc.
Heart-Shaped Swirl Lollipops - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13823121
Starting at
$9.38
(15)
 
 
Select Options
 
1 1/2" x 3 3/4" 4-Color Scooby-Doo!™ Crayon Boxes - 24 Pc.
1 1/2" x 3 3/4" 4-Color Scooby-Doo!™ Crayon Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14512423
On
Sale
$7.88
10% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Personalized Jesus Loves You Slime Containers
Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Personalized Jesus Loves You Slime Containers
48 Piece(s) #13932858
$24.99
 
 
Select Options
Quick View
2 1/4" x 3" Little Town of Bethlehem Wood Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
2 1/4" x 3" Little Town of Bethlehem Wood Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13780266
$16.99
(53)
 
 
Quick View
3" Names of Jesus Gray, Brown & White Wood Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
3" Names of Jesus Gray, Brown & White Wood Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13957752
$16.99
(33)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk Charms® Party Pack Candy Assortment - 2 lbs, 100 pc
Bulk Charms® Party Pack Candy Assortment - 2 lbs, 100 pc
100 Piece(s) #/K1384
On
Sale
$16.68
12% OFF
(32)
 
 
Quick View
5" Mini World of Eric Carle Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See? Puzzles - 12 Pc.
5" Mini World of Eric Carle Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See? Puzzles - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13720649
$7.99
(21)
 
 
Quick View
5 1/2" Bulk 72 Pc. Personalized Red Plastic Retractable Pens
5 1/2" Bulk 72 Pc. Personalized Red Plastic Retractable Pens
72 Piece(s) #13983763
$59.99
(15)
 
 
Select Options
Quick View
9 1/2" x 8 1/2" Bright Colorful Plastic Bucket Assortment - 4 Pc.
9 1/2" x 8 1/2" Bright Colorful Plastic Bucket Assortment - 4 Pc.
1 Set(s) #3/1908
$21.99
(11)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Fish Mochi Squishies - 12 Pc.
Mini Fish Mochi Squishies - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13814316
$12.49
(4)
 
 
Quick View
2" Mini Letter Brightly Colored Plastic Brain Teaser Games - 12 Pc.
2" Mini Letter Brightly Colored Plastic Brain Teaser Games - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #12/2490
$9.99
(23)
 
 
Quick View
Exciting Dinosaur Fossil Toy-Filled Plastic Easter Eggs - 12 Pc.
Exciting Dinosaur Fossil Toy-Filled Plastic Easter Eggs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13936584
$16.99
(30)
 
 
Quick View
Strawberries ’N Cream Heart-Shaped Lollipops - 38 Pc.
Strawberries ’N Cream Heart-Shaped Lollipops - 38 Pc.
38 Piece(s) #/K6250
$7.99
(89)
 
 
Quick View
11" Inflatable World of Eric Carle The Very Hungry Caterpillar™ Beach Balls - 12 Pc.
11" Inflatable World of Eric Carle The Very Hungry Caterpillar™ Beach Balls - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13733644
On
Sale
$15.98
20% OFF
(24)
 
 
Quick View
Kids Harry Potter™ Hermione Necklace
Kids Harry Potter™ Hermione Necklace
1 Piece(s) #DG108749
$13.99
 
 
Quick View
Color Your Own Spring Birds - 24 Pc.
Color Your Own Spring Birds - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13944216
$16.99
 
 
Quick View
Fun Dr. Seuss The Cat in the Hat Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
Fun Dr. Seuss The Cat in the Hat Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14356011
$21.99
(3)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Bulk 50 Pc. Trendy Self-Inking Plastic Stamper Assortment
1 1/2" Bulk 50 Pc. Trendy Self-Inking Plastic Stamper Assortment
50 Piece(s) #13838555
$19.99
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Cat-Shaped Bouncy Balls - 12 Pc.
Cat-Shaped Bouncy Balls - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13962311
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$7.49
(7)
 
 
Quick View
Pop Rocks® Bubble Gum Hard Candy - 24 Pc.
Pop Rocks® Bubble Gum Hard Candy - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13822890
$30.99
(4)
 
 
Quick View
1" Multicolor Rubber Jewel Rings with Detachable Gem - 24 Pc.
1" Multicolor Rubber Jewel Rings with Detachable Gem - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #24/2416
$7.99
(15)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Religious Thrill of Hope Wood Christmas Ornament - 12 Pc.
3 1/2" Religious Thrill of Hope Wood Christmas Ornament - 12 Pc.
12 Piece(s) #14469972
$12.99
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Colored Glass Christmas Ball Ornaments - 20 Pc.
Mini Colored Glass Christmas Ball Ornaments - 20 Pc.
20 Piece(s) #14133181
Clearance
Price
$16.97
5% OFF
(4)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Mini Basketball-Themed Rubber Ducks – 24 Pc.
1 1/2" Mini Basketball-Themed Rubber Ducks – 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #42/4324
$12.99
(11)
 
 
Quick View
90s Icon Keychains - 12 Pc.
90s Icon Keychains - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13980747
$9.99
 
 
Quick View
2 1/2" Mini Farm Animal Cow, Horse, Pig & Chicken Vinyl Finger Puppets – 12 Pc.
2 1/2" Mini Farm Animal Cow, Horse, Pig & Chicken Vinyl Finger Puppets – 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14095922
$7.79
 
 
Quick View
2 lbs. White Foil-Wrapped Caramel Chewable Candies - 189 Pc.
2 lbs. White Foil-Wrapped Caramel Chewable Candies - 189 Pc.
189 Piece(s) #13745413
$10.48
(292)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Winter Images Neutral Wood Slice Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
3 1/2" Winter Images Neutral Wood Slice Christmas Ornaments - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14465228
$16.99
 
 
Quick View
Bulk 60 Pc. Tissue Paper Sheets
Bulk 60 Pc. Tissue Paper Sheets
60 Sheet(s) #13601700
Starting at
$7.99
(136)
 
 
Select Options
 
Countdown 12 Days of Christmas Ornaments Gift Set
Countdown 12 Days of Christmas Ornaments Gift Set
1 Set(s) #14133113
Clearance
Price
$7.47
62% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Valentine Arrow Pencils with Eraser Toppers - 24 Pc.
Valentine Arrow Pencils with Eraser Toppers - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13756457
$8.29
(23)
 
 
Quick View
2" Multicolor Swirl Pattern Metal YoYos – 12 Pc.
2" Multicolor Swirl Pattern Metal YoYos – 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13720979
$5.99
(9)
 
 
Quick View
4" Legend of the Holiday Pineapple Resin Christmas Ornaments with Card for 12
4" Legend of the Holiday Pineapple Resin Christmas Ornaments with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13956326
$16.99
(17)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk 72 Pc. Emoji Temporary Tattoo Assortment
Bulk 72 Pc. Emoji Temporary Tattoo Assortment
72 Piece(s) #13736378
On
Sale
$6.88
11% OFF
(14)
 
 
Quick View
4 1/2" Valentine's Day Stuffed Labradoodles with Heart Bandana - 12 Pc.
4 1/2" Valentine's Day Stuffed Labradoodles with Heart Bandana - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13814829
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.99
(23)
 
 
Quick View
2" Bulk 144 Pc. Mini Valentine's Day Plastic Jumping Hearts
2" Bulk 144 Pc. Mini Valentine's Day Plastic Jumping Hearts
144 Piece(s) #13933258
$9.78
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Religious Mini Jesus Figure Parachute Toys - 12 Pc.
1 1/2" Religious Mini Jesus Figure Parachute Toys - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14553114
$8.29
 
 
Quick View
1 3/4" Classic Wood Cross Keychains with Metal Chain - 12 Pc.
1 3/4" Classic Wood Cross Keychains with Metal Chain - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #19/145
On
Sale
$5.78
14% OFF
(61)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Bright Colors Disco Ball Necklaces Assortment - 12 Pc.
1 1/2" Bright Colors Disco Ball Necklaces Assortment - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #24/201
On
Sale
$6.98
12% OFF
(19)
 
 
Quick View
4 1/2" x 5 3/4" Religious Walking Jesus Wind-Up Craft Kit - Makes 10
4 1/2" x 5 3/4" Religious Walking Jesus Wind-Up Craft Kit - Makes 10
Makes 10 #14474796
$9.99
(3)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Legend of the Hummingbird Christmas Ornaments with Card for 12
3 1/2" Legend of the Hummingbird Christmas Ornaments with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13778511
$21.99
(46)
 
 
Quick View
4" x 5" Religious Angel with Heart Metal Ornaments – 6 Pc.
4" x 5" Religious Angel with Heart Metal Ornaments – 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #14514295
$17.99
 
 
Quick View
1" – 5" SpongeBob SquarePants™ Character Wooden Nesting Dolls – 5 Pc.
1" – 5" SpongeBob SquarePants™ Character Wooden Nesting Dolls – 5 Pc.
5 Piece(s) #14572454
$8.99
 
 
Quick View
3 3/4" Mini Bright Color Stuffed Plush Cat Characters - 12 Pc.
3 3/4" Mini Bright Color Stuffed Plush Cat Characters - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #6/1477
$19.99
(33)
 
 
Quick View
Discovery Shark Week™ Slap Bracelets - 12 Pc.
Discovery Shark Week™ Slap Bracelets - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14103920
On
Sale
$5.98
14% OFF
 
 
Quick View
1" x 2 1/2" Bulk 48 Pc. Dr. Seuss™ Characters Beveled Rubber Erasers
1" x 2 1/2" Bulk 48 Pc. Dr. Seuss™ Characters Beveled Rubber Erasers
48 Piece(s) #13638163
$24.99
(7)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" Textured Blue, Red & Yellow Foam Stress Toys - 12 Pc.
3 1/2" Textured Blue, Red & Yellow Foam Stress Toys - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13806471
$16.99
(7)
 
 
Quick View
Orange Stuffed Tigers - 12 Pc.
Orange Stuffed Tigers - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14090713
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.99
(6)
 
 
Quick View
Valentine Dinosaur Card Holder Box Craft Kit - Makes 1
Valentine Dinosaur Card Holder Box Craft Kit - Makes 1
Makes 1 #14194108
Clearance
Price
$2.97
54% OFF
(4)
 
 
Quick View
1 ... 11 12 13 ... 24