Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Skip Left Nav
Jump to Top of List

Top-Rated Valentine's Day Party Favors & Exchange Items

(311 items)
4" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Valentine's Day Heart Containers with Stuffed Bear
4" Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Valentine's Day Heart Containers with Stuffed Bear
48 Piece(s) #14330254
Kit
Price
$72.99
SAVE 20%
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk Knot Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 72
Bulk Knot Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 72
72 Piece(s) #13958422
$14.99
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Hugging Stuffed Sloth Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Hugging Stuffed Sloth Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13933184
$27.99
(11)
 
 
Quick View
Grandma's Big Cookie Chocolate Chip, 2.5 oz, 60 Count
Grandma's Big Cookie Chocolate Chip, 2.5 oz, 60 Count
60 Count #13966438
$71.99
Shipped by Green Rabbit
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Sign Language Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Sign Language Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #14194973
$10.99
 
 
Quick View
DIY Medium White Polyester Drawstring Bags - 12 pc
DIY Medium White Polyester Drawstring Bags - 12 pc
12 Piece(s) #57/9068
$24.99
(25)
 
 
Quick View
SKINNY POP 100 Calorie Popcorn Snack - 28 Pieces
SKINNY POP 100 Calorie Popcorn Snack - 28 Pieces
28 Piece(s) #13966189
$35.99
Shipped by Green Rabbit
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Unicorn Candy Bracelets Valentine Exchanges for 12
Unicorn Candy Bracelets Valentine Exchanges for 12
Per Dozen #13814709
Kit
Price
$6.98
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Heart-Shaped Glitter Top Containers - 12 Pc.
Heart-Shaped Glitter Top Containers - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13933256
Clearance
Price
$7.67
44% OFF
 
 
Quick View
28 oz. Smarties® Candy Love Hearts Valentine Exchanges - 32 Pc.
28 oz. Smarties® Candy Love Hearts Valentine Exchanges - 32 Pc.
32 Piece(s) #13912843
$21.99
(11)
 
 
Quick View
Love Wedding Playing Cards - 12 Pc.
Love Wedding Playing Cards - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #47/687
$9.99
(31)
 
 
Quick View
Nerdy Clear Lens Glasses Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Nerdy Clear Lens Glasses Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13933163
Kit
Price
$8.58
SAVE 25%
(14)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Handyman Nuts & Bolts Valentine Exchange Packs - 12 Pc.
Mini Handyman Nuts & Bolts Valentine Exchange Packs - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13962396
On
Sale
$17.58
20% OFF
(2)
 
 
Quick View
5" Stuffed Pizza Slices Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
5" Stuffed Pizza Slices Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13784179
$21.99
Backorder Available
Est. Shipping Date: Wed, Nov 11
(39)
 
 
Quick View
3 3/4" x 4" Horse Bendables Valentine Exchanges with Cowboy Card for 24
3 3/4" x 4" Horse Bendables Valentine Exchanges with Cowboy Card for 24
24 Piece(s) #13933415
Kit
Price
$19.98
(9)
 
 
Quick View
5" x 11 1/2" Bulk 144 Pc. Valentine’s Day Cellophane Bag Assortment
5" x 11 1/2" Bulk 144 Pc. Valentine’s Day Cellophane Bag Assortment
144 Piece(s) #13819984
On
Sale
$11.48
36% OFF
Backorder Available
Est. Shipping Date: Sun, Nov 29
(18)
 
 
Quick View
4 1/2" x 2 3/4" Valentine's Day Cardstock Cupcake Boxes - 12 Pc.
4 1/2" x 2 3/4" Valentine's Day Cardstock Cupcake Boxes - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #32/1301
On
Sale
$5.18
42% OFF
(21)
 
 
Quick View
Valentine Bean Bag Toss Game
Valentine Bean Bag Toss Game
1 Set(s) #13719784
On
Sale
$19.98
9% OFF
(12)
 
 
Quick View
6" Stuffed White Caticorns Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
6" Stuffed White Caticorns Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #13819221
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.99
(12)
 
 
Quick View
Black Chalkboard Label Favor Tags
Black Chalkboard Label Favor Tags
Per Dozen #13829524
Clearance
Price
$4.27
57% OFF
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Playful Chef: Deluxe Cake Decorating Studio
Playful Chef: Deluxe Cake Decorating Studio
1 Piece(s) #13937383
$44.99
 
 
Quick View
13" Multicolor Bendable Smile Face Stuffed Flowers – 12 Pc.
13" Multicolor Bendable Smile Face Stuffed Flowers – 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #6/1752
$21.99
(30)
 
 
Quick View
Valentine Arrow Pencils with Eraser Toppers - 24 Pc.
Valentine Arrow Pencils with Eraser Toppers - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13756457
Clearance
Price
$7.47
9% OFF
(23)
 
 
Quick View
4" Mini Valentine’s Day Hugging Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
4" Mini Valentine’s Day Hugging Stuffed Bears - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #32/194
Clearance
Price
$34.37
23% OFF
(10)
 
 
Quick View
Two Hearts Stick Pens - 24 Pc.
Two Hearts Stick Pens - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13608393
On
Sale
$15.18
20% OFF
(16)
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Mini Neon Smile Face Solid Color Foam Stress Balls - 24 Pc.
1 1/2" Mini Neon Smile Face Solid Color Foam Stress Balls - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #12/2298
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$21.99
(60)
 
 
Quick View
Clear Cylinder Boxes - 12 Pc.
Clear Cylinder Boxes - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13781829
Clearance
Price
$9.87
10% OFF
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Personalized Jesus Loves You Slime Containers
Bulk 48 Pc. Mini Personalized Jesus Loves You Slime Containers
48 Piece(s) #13932858
$24.99
 
 
Select Options
Quick View
3.75 lbs. Bulk 375 Pc. Purple Foil-Wrapped Hershey’s® Kisses® Chocolate Candy
3.75 lbs. Bulk 375 Pc. Purple Foil-Wrapped Hershey’s® Kisses® Chocolate Candy
375 Piece(s) #13774915
$60.99
(280)
 
 
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Roly-Poly Lion, Elephant, Giraffe, Tiger Stuffed Animals - 12 Pc.
Mini Valentine’s Day Roly-Poly Lion, Elephant, Giraffe, Tiger Stuffed Animals - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13756446
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.97
SAVE 13%
(19)
 
 
Quick View
Large Red Paracord Bracelets - 6 Pc.
Large Red Paracord Bracelets - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #13651703
$10.99
(33)
 
 
Quick View
Personalized Open Text Stuffed Teddy Bear with T-Shirt
Personalized Open Text Stuffed Teddy Bear with T-Shirt
1 Piece(s) #13697444
$13.99
(21)
 
 
Select Options
Quick View
Stuffed Dog with Lollipop Valentine Exchanges for 12
Stuffed Dog with Lollipop Valentine Exchanges for 12
Per Dozen #13718296
Kit
Price
$31.98
SAVE 34%
(27)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk Mini Stuffed Animal Assortment Valentine Exchanges with Card for 48
Bulk Mini Stuffed Animal Assortment Valentine Exchanges with Card for 48
48 Piece(s) #13718867
$54.99
Backorder Available
Est. Shipping Date: Wed, Dec 9
(54)
 
 
Quick View
Emoji Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 24
Emoji Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 24
24 Piece(s) #13756228
Clearance
Price
$7.47
56% OFF
(19)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk Smart Watch Slap Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 50
Bulk Smart Watch Slap Bracelet Valentine Exchanges with Card for 50
50 Piece(s) #13933214
Clearance
Price
$15.97
36% OFF
(12)
 
 
Quick View
Small Valentine Fringe Gift Bags - 6 Pc.
Small Valentine Fringe Gift Bags - 6 Pc.
6 Piece(s) #13933259
Clearance
Price
$4.77
65% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Mini Inflatable 5" Classic Beach Balls with Card - 12 Pc.
Mini Inflatable 5" Classic Beach Balls with Card - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13942749
$14.99
(3)
 
 
Quick View
30" Bulk 48 Pc. Happy Valentine's Day Beaded Necklaces
30" Bulk 48 Pc. Happy Valentine's Day Beaded Necklaces
48 Piece(s) #13961299
On
Sale
$14.48
42% OFF
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Dr. Seuss™ Handout Kit for 48
Dr. Seuss™ Handout Kit for 48
282 Piece(s) #14092769
Kit
Price
$94.99
SAVE 22%
 
 
Quick View
Mini Valentine’s Day Red Stuffed Gnomes - 12 Pc.
Mini Valentine’s Day Red Stuffed Gnomes - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14095437
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.99
Backorder Available
Est. Shipping Date: Wed, Dec 9
(8)
 
 
Quick View
5" Stuffed Waffle Valentine Exchanges with Syrup Card for 12
5" Stuffed Waffle Valentine Exchanges with Syrup Card for 12
Per Dozen #14095544
$21.99
(3)
 
 
Quick View
12" x 15" Medium Nonwoven Discovery Shark Week™ Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
12" x 15" Medium Nonwoven Discovery Shark Week™ Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14112637
$27.99
 
 
Quick View
Stuffed Dr. Seuss™ Walking Thing 1 & Thing 2 Puppets - 12 Pc.
Stuffed Dr. Seuss™ Walking Thing 1 & Thing 2 Puppets - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14145506
$32.99
 
 
Quick View
Bulk Food Necklace Valentine Exchanges with Card for 48
Bulk Food Necklace Valentine Exchanges with Card for 48
48 Piece(s) #14330216
Kit
Price
$29.98
SAVE 24%
 
 
Quick View
6-Color Rainbow Crayon Valentine Exchanges with Card for 25
6-Color Rainbow Crayon Valentine Exchanges with Card for 25
25 Piece(s) #14357408
Kit
Price
$11.98
 
 
Quick View
7 1/2" Wild Color Rainbow Pencil Valentine Exchanges with It's Cool to Be Kind Card for 24
7 1/2" Wild Color Rainbow Pencil Valentine Exchanges with It's Cool to Be Kind Card for 24
24 Piece(s) #14359771
Kit
Price
$5.78
SAVE 14%
 
 
Quick View
5" x 4 1/2" x 2" Pink Square Cardstock Party Favor Boxes - 12 Pc.
5" x 4 1/2" x 2" Pink Square Cardstock Party Favor Boxes - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14434585
Clearance
Price
$3.57
34% OFF
 
 
Quick View
12 3/4" x 15 1/2" Large Red Nylon Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
12 3/4" x 15 1/2" Large Red Nylon Drawstring Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14/452-RD
On
Sale
$16.98
15% OFF
(15)
 
 
Quick View
24 Pc. 7 1/4" Dog Man™ Do Good Character Bracelets with Card for 24
24 Pc. 7 1/4" Dog Man™ Do Good Character Bracelets with Card for 24
24 Piece(s) #14512346
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$6.99
 
 
Quick View
Personalized Valentine T-Shirt Brown Stuffed Bear
Personalized Valentine T-Shirt Brown Stuffed Bear
Each #32/1208
$13.99
(42)
 
 
Select Options
Quick View
4" - 5" Stuffed Silly Sports Balls Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
4" - 5" Stuffed Silly Sports Balls Valentine Exchanges with Card for 12
Per Dozen #32/1239
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$19.99
Backorder Available
Est. Shipping Date: Wed, Dec 9
(32)
 
 
Quick View
7 1/2" Bulk 72 Pc. Wooden Pencils with Assorted Pencil Top Erasers
7 1/2" Bulk 72 Pc. Wooden Pencils with Assorted Pencil Top Erasers
72 Piece(s) #5/1734
$59.99
(5)
 
 
Quick View
White Foil-Wrapped Chocolate Candy Roses - 12 Pc.
White Foil-Wrapped Chocolate Candy Roses - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #/K1481
$27.99
(21)
 
 
Quick View
Kid Power! Super Fun Valentine Pack of 28
Kid Power! Super Fun Valentine Pack of 28
28 Piece(s) #VPS62
$12.99
 
 
Quick View
1 2 3 4 5