Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Skip Left Nav
Jump to Top of List

Affordable Themed Party Supplies & Decorations Under $5

(5072 items)
Caveman Club
Caveman Club
1 Piece(s) #VA17
On
Sale
$3.98
66% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Mini Striped Candy Pink & White Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
Mini Striped Candy Pink & White Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13805776
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$2.98
SAVE 54%
This item is out-of-stock.
(52)
 
 
See Details
 
7" Purr-fect Party Cats Disposable Paper Dessert Plates – 8 Ct.
7" Purr-fect Party Cats Disposable Paper Dessert Plates – 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13818531
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
54" x 108" Groovy Retro Plastic Table Cover
54" x 108" Groovy Retro Plastic Table Cover
1 Piece(s) #14115485
On
Sale
$4.38
12% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
7 1/4" Colorful Birthday Cats Party Round Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
7 1/4" Colorful Birthday Cats Party Round Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14468460
$2.68
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Camouflage Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Camouflage Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13652470
$3.29
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
7 3/4" Blue Awareness Ribbon Pop-Out Rubber Bracelets - 24 Pc.
7 3/4" Blue Awareness Ribbon Pop-Out Rubber Bracelets - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13698745
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
(55)
 
 
See Details
 
Basketball Party Basketball Player Silhouette Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Basketball Party Basketball Player Silhouette Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14091951
$2.68
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Mehron Cheek Powder
Mehron Cheek Powder
1 Piece(s) #DD202MJ
On
Sale
$3.98
55% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Peeps® Pink Marshmallow Chicks
Peeps® Pink Marshmallow Chicks
5 Piece(s) #14109188
$2.79
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Backyard BBQ Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Backyard BBQ Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #14208819
On
Sale
$2.48
24% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Elevated Luau Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Elevated Luau Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #14209240
$2.79
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Unicorn Solar Shine Ups Night Light
Unicorn Solar Shine Ups Night Light
1 Piece(s) #14122946
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$4.29
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Oktoberfest Blue & White Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
Oktoberfest Blue & White Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14393253
$2.68
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Toxictoons™ Lil Frankee Bubble Gum Fear Freshener
Toxictoons™ Lil Frankee Bubble Gum Fear Freshener
1 Piece(s) #MATTEP129
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
54" x 108" Paw Print Party Plastic Tablecloth
54" x 108" Paw Print Party Plastic Tablecloth
1 Piece(s) #14208812
On
Sale
$4.38
12% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
9 1/4" Bowling Party Strike Round Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
9 1/4" Bowling Party Strike Round Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14434448
$2.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Unicorn Birthday Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Unicorn Birthday Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13838501
On
Sale
$2.68
18% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
7 1/2" x 9 1/2" Dr. Seuss™ Hat-Shaped Disposable Paper Dessert Plates – 8 Ct.
7 1/2" x 9 1/2" Dr. Seuss™ Hat-Shaped Disposable Paper Dessert Plates – 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13961846
$2.79
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
Oh Happy Day Stickers
Oh Happy Day Stickers
6 Sheet(s) #13980986
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
1.5 oz. PEEPS® Yellow Marshmallow Chicks
1.5 oz. PEEPS® Yellow Marshmallow Chicks
5 Piece(s) #14109186
BUY MORE
& SAVE
$2.19
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre™ Leatherface Scented Fear Freshener
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre™ Leatherface Scented Fear Freshener
1 Piece(s) #MABXRL107
$4.39
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
DIY Shoe Chains Happy & Dream Beaded Craft Kit - Makes 2
DIY Shoe Chains Happy & Dream Beaded Craft Kit - Makes 2
Makes 2 #14577451
$3.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
8" DIY Smile Face Beaded Plastic Shoe Chain Accessory Craft Kit
8" DIY Smile Face Beaded Plastic Shoe Chain Accessory Craft Kit
Makes 1 #14577450
$3.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Axolotl Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
Axolotl Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14371601
$3.29
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Krampus™ Krampus Christmas Tree Fear Freshener
Krampus™ Krampus Christmas Tree Fear Freshener
1 Piece(s) #MABXLE111
$4.09
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Toxictoons™ Maggoty Muck Vanilla Fear Freshener
Toxictoons™ Maggoty Muck Vanilla Fear Freshener
Each #MATTEP122
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
7 ft. Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Valentine Ready-to-Hang Cardstock Garland
7 ft. Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Valentine Ready-to-Hang Cardstock Garland
1 Piece(s) #14619788
$3.99
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
6" Valentine's Day Stacking Heart Pencils - 12 Pc.
6" Valentine's Day Stacking Heart Pencils - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13819917
On
Sale
$2.98
60% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
(4)
 
 
See Details
 
Unicorn Birthday Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Unicorn Birthday Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13838499
$2.68
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Spa Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Spa Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14393225
$2.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
1 1/4" x 7" Snake Beaded Chenille Stem Craft Kit - Makes 12
1 1/4" x 7" Snake Beaded Chenille Stem Craft Kit - Makes 12
Makes 12 #14468196
On
Sale
$4.48
59% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Tackle Breast Cancer Big Band Rubber Bracelets - 12 Pc.
Tackle Breast Cancer Big Band Rubber Bracelets - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13657612
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
(8)
 
 
See Details
 
4 3/8" x 5 1/2" Small Neon Gift Bags - 12 Pc.
4 3/8" x 5 1/2" Small Neon Gift Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #3/181
$4.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(16)
 
 
See Details
 
7 1/4" Golf Party Round Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
7 1/4" Golf Party Round Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Unit(s) #14393155
$2.68
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
54" x 108" Red & White Stripe Plastic Tablecloth
54" x 108" Red & White Stripe Plastic Tablecloth
1 Piece(s) #14091959
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Bright Mother’s Day Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Bright Mother’s Day Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14106081
$4.49
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
90th Birthday Burst Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
90th Birthday Burst Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14152099
$2.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
8 3/4" x 6" Despicable Me 4 Minions Cardstock Goggles - 8 Pc.
8 3/4" x 6" Despicable Me 4 Minions Cardstock Goggles - 8 Pc.
8 Piece(s) #14526356
$2.29
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
7 1/4" SpongeBob SquarePants™ Disposable Paper Dessert Plates with Yellow Trim – 8 Ct.
7 1/4" SpongeBob SquarePants™ Disposable Paper Dessert Plates with Yellow Trim – 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14542569
$2.79
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
8mm x 15mm Bulk 50 Pc. Bright Yellow Solid Color Metal Brads
8mm x 15mm Bulk 50 Pc. Bright Yellow Solid Color Metal Brads
50 Piece(s) #14613767
$4.79
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
7 1/2" Jesus Is the Light VBS Wood Pencils - 24 Pc.
7 1/2" Jesus Is the Light VBS Wood Pencils - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #14648858
On
Sale
$4.68
21% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Mehron Paradise Makeup AQ™ 1/8 In Flat Brush
Mehron Paradise Makeup AQ™ 1/8 In Flat Brush
1 Piece(s) #DD812
On
Sale
$3.98
45% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Small Peanuts® Snoopy Activity Paper Treat Bags - 12 Pc.
Small Peanuts® Snoopy Activity Paper Treat Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14371591
On
Sale
$4.98
13% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
8 3/4" Unicorn Party Shaped Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 3/4" Unicorn Party Shaped Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14468521
$2.49
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
The Twilight Zone™ Mystic Seer Machine Vanilla Fear Freshener
The Twilight Zone™ Mystic Seer Machine Vanilla Fear Freshener
Each #MASFCBS111
$4.19
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Color Your Own 100th Day of School Bookmarks - 12 Pc.
Color Your Own 100th Day of School Bookmarks - 12 Pc.
12 Piece(s) #13934870
On
Sale
$3.48
48% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
6 1/4" Fiesta Sombrero Party Paper Glasses - 12 Pc.
6 1/4" Fiesta Sombrero Party Paper Glasses - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13836804
$4.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(2)
 
 
See Details
 
5 1/2" x 3 1/4" x 11" Medium Shamrock Cellophane Bags - 12 Pc.
5 1/2" x 3 1/4" x 11" Medium Shamrock Cellophane Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #26/1409
$2.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(13)
 
 
See Details
 
Mini Green Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
Mini Green Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #3/3589
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(110)
 
 
See Details
 
Mini Blue Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
Mini Blue Popcorn Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #3/3585
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(110)
 
 
See Details
 
9" Assorted Metallic Star Hanging Cardboard Decorations – 12 Pc.
9" Assorted Metallic Star Hanging Cardboard Decorations – 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #70/1138
$4.69
This item is out-of-stock.
(151)
 
 
See Details
 
Religious Watercolor Bookmarks - 24 Pc.
Religious Watercolor Bookmarks - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #13962075
$4.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(7)
 
 
See Details
 
4 3/4" Bear Stacking Point Plastic Pencils - 12 Pc.
4 3/4" Bear Stacking Point Plastic Pencils - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #9/594
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
12" Bulk 100 Pc. Essentials By Leisure Arts Beige Chenille Stems
12" Bulk 100 Pc. Essentials By Leisure Arts Beige Chenille Stems
100 Piece(s) #14613789
$3.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
5" x 1 1/4" Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Magnetic Metal Bookmarks - 12 Pc.
5" x 1 1/4" Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Magnetic Metal Bookmarks - 12 Pc.
12 Piece(s) #14600042
$4.39
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
54" x 108" Graduation Cap Rectangle Disposable Plastic Tablecloth
54" x 108" Graduation Cap Rectangle Disposable Plastic Tablecloth
1 Piece(s) #14371525
On
Sale
$2.48
50% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
30" Hanging Valentine Hearts Swirl Decorations – 12 Pc.
30" Hanging Valentine Hearts Swirl Decorations – 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14359798
On
Sale
$4.38
43% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
6 1/2" Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins – 16 Ct.
6 1/2" Peanuts® Snoopy & Woodstock Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins – 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14371586
On
Sale
$3.27
13% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
96" x 54" Transporation Time Party Rectangle Paper Tablecloth
96" x 54" Transporation Time Party Rectangle Paper Tablecloth
1 Piece(s) #14468721
$4.49
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
The Return of the Living Dead™ Party Time Skeleton Cinnamon Fear Freshener
The Return of the Living Dead™ Party Time Skeleton Cinnamon Fear Freshener
Each #MASFEM103
$4.99
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Pineapple Aloha Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Pineapple Aloha Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13788299
On
Sale
$2.68
18% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
4 1/4" x 3 1/4" Valentine's Day Pink & Blue Cow Magnets Craft Kit - Makes 12
4 1/4" x 3 1/4" Valentine's Day Pink & Blue Cow Magnets Craft Kit - Makes 12
Makes 12 #14473369
On
Sale
$4.98
43% OFF
This item is out-of-stock.
 
 
See Details
 
Mini White Favor Boxes - 24 Pc.
Mini White Favor Boxes - 24 Pc.
24 Piece(s) #3/3611
$3.49
This item is out-of-stock.
(48)
 
 
See Details
 
1 ... 73 74 75 ... 80