PB & J Milkshake Recipe

1 min read September 13, 2026 Michelle Stewart
Share this article

Do you love PB & Js? My boys sure do. I recently styled a “We Go Together Like PB & J” Valentine’s Day Party for my boys, and of course I had to include their favorite PB & J Milkshakes! If you’re planning a party, playdate, or any celebration worthy of a delicious and easy recipe, you’ll want to give my recipe a try!

Recipe Time
10 to 20 min
Difficulty
Beginner
Servings
1 to 2 Servings
Ingredients:
Makes 2 Milkshakes
  • 1 c. Milk
  • 1 c. Vanilla Ice Cream
  • 1/3 c. Peanut Butter and Jelly
  • 1/8 c. Crushed Ice
  • *For Thicker Shakes, use 3/4 milk and 1 1/4 c. Ice Cream
Step
1

Combine the milk, ice cream and peanut butter and jelly mixture into a blender or carafe, if using a hand blender.

Blend for 20 seconds.

Add crushed ice and blend for 20 seconds.

PB & J Milkshake Recipe step 1
Step
2

Serve in a large glass with a paper straw and enjoy!

Be sure to check out all the other details from my “We Go Together Like PB & J” Valentine’s Day Party including the tutorials for my PB & J Tassel Garland and PB & J Favor Boxes and Tags, plus my adorable Mini Milk Carton Party Favor Boxes.

PB & J Milkshake Recipe step 2

Oriental Trading is your go-to source for party supplies, crafts, toys, and novelties. With over 85 years of experience, we offer a wide selection of products at unbeatable prices, making it easy to create memorable celebrations.

Learn more about us