Super Mario Toadstool Pops

2 min read September 14, 2026 Missy and Kristen
Share this article

Nothing makes throwing a party easier than having a quick, no bake, adorable themed treat to serve up! This recipe for Toadstool Marshmallow Pops is time saving, cost effective and a surefire hot with your Super Mario fans! With chocolate, marshmallows and candy, these marshmallow pops are a great way to ensure your party is a smash!

Recipe Time
10 to 20 min
Difficulty
Beginner
Servings
10 to 15 Servings
Ingredients:
Makes 12 Marshmallow Pops
  • Marshmallows
  • Vanilla Icing
  • White Chocolate
  • Red Food Coloring
  • Edible Pen
  • Lime Green Gumballs
Step
1

Start by breaking your chocolate into chunks to allow it to melt faster and more easily.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 1
Step
2

Then, melt your white chocolate in the microwave in 30 second increments, making sure to stir in between.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 2
Step
3

Add a few drops of red food coloring to create the perfect red tone for the toadstool.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 3
Step
4

Insert paper straws in the base of the marshmallows. Dip roughly half of the marshmallow into the red chocolate and allow to fully set and harden.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 4
Step
5

Add some white icing dots to the toadstool.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 5
Step
6

Now, using a food safe edible pen, add the eyes (two small lines).

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 6
Step
7

To create a fun display fill a mason jar with gumballs and add a star to the front. Place the pops inside for a fun detail.

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 7
Step
8

Serve your pops at your Super Mario party and enjoy!

 

Be sure to check out the whole Super Mario Party, DIY Centerpiece and Mario Party Backdrop

Super Mario Toadstool Pops step 8

Oriental Trading is your go-to source for party supplies, crafts, toys, and novelties. With over 85 years of experience, we offer a wide selection of products at unbeatable prices, making it easy to create memorable celebrations.

Learn more about us